meta eyJzcmNCdWNrZXQiOiJiemdsZmlsZXMifQ 1
Son Stone on “Memory of Sugar”: Exploring Temptation, Innocence, and Unexpected Turns in Songwriting 3

In his latest release, “Memory of Sugar,” singer-songwriter Son Stone takes listeners into an unexpected story of youthful curiosity, innocence, and temptation, told with a playful sense of humor. Originally written in 2014 and recorded in 2022, the song remained unreleased for years before finding its way back into the spotlight. Inspired by an open DADADE guitar tuning, the track also marks a departure from his usual folk and Americana sound, revealing a different side of his songwriting. In this interview, Son Stone discusses the story behind the song, the creative freedom of experimenting with new tunings, and what finally convinced him to share this unconventional track with the world.

1. “Memory of Sugar” tells the story of a young man living independently for the first time who finds himself in an unexpected encounter with an older, confident woman. What inspired this storyline, and how did the idea first come to you?

Sometimes I let the muse take me where she wants to go.  I was playing around with chord shapes in a new open tuning (DADADE) and started free-associating lyrics. “She was a goddess in a tee shirt and jeans” came out.  I though, “Oh .. this could be a good beginning for a country song!”  The next line that came was “She looked like an angel from one of my dreams” and now I needed a rhyme for “dreams” and in rapid fire, “I was too shy to approach her, I was only sixteen” came out and by then I was committed to writing a story about an older woman and a young narrator.

2. You originally wrote the song in 2014, but it wasn’t recorded until December 2022 and is only now being released. Why did you decide to revisit it after all those years?

I recorded it as part of a demo with a new producer I was working with, Chris Fasulo. He wanted to showcase a folky song of mine with some more pop elements (percussion, lead electric guitar, and bass, on top of my fingerstyle guitar work).  I really liked it when it was done, but the subject matter was edgy and it didn’t reflect the folk vibe I was going for at the time, so I buried it.  It’s been four years since the recording, and I guess that gave me enough emotional space to separate from it.  When I accidentally found it again, I said “Oh! I like this! I should release this!”

3. You’ve described “Memory of Sugar” as a little risqué and quite different from your usual material. Was stepping outside your typical songwriting style exciting, challenging, or perhaps a little uncomfortable?

There are a lot of “confessional” writers out there.  I ain’t one of them.  I write stories about characters I make up, but the songs often come off sounding deeply personal.  (That’s my job as a song writer, right?)  Listeners often think I’m writing about my life (aka “biographical fallacy”).  It’s not uncomfortable to write this type of song, because I’m always writing from the perspective of other characters.  (I’ve written from the perspective of biblical characters, con men, alcohol and drug abusers, jilted lovers, dogs, I even wrote a song from the perspective of a grape getting crushed to make wine.)  In a live setting, I can set the song up.  The discomfort with a song like “Memory of Sugar” comes in releasing it publicly because I can’t explain the context to the listener.   The song needs to be able to stand up on its own, and I think this song does.  Still, it’s unnerving.  It’s like sending your child off to their first day of school.

4. The song explores innocence, temptation, and youthful curiosity with a playful sense of humor. What did you want listeners to take away from the story? 

Exactly that! “Innocence, temptation, and youthful curiosity with a playful sense of humor.”

5. There’s an interesting balance between what the lyrics reveal and what they leave to the imagination. Was that ambiguity intentional, and did you enjoy giving listeners room to interpret the story for themselves?

Yes, the lyrics walk the edge of a very fine line in this one.  We’re talking about a naïve, 16-year-old boy and a woman who’s older and more experienced.  The song would fall dangerously over the line if it were any more explicit, so I’m glad the lyrics left most of the action to imagination.

6. Musically, you used an open DADADE guitar tuning to create the song’s distinctive sound. What attracted you to this particular tuning, and how did it influence the composition and arrangement?

I’ve played Hawaiian Slack Key guitar for 30 years.  There are over 60 recorded tunings in Hawaiian Slack Key.  I play 8 or 9 of them.  Whenever I hit a plateau in my writing and playing, I change tunings and it’s like learning a new instrument. It really frees up the creativity.  My friend Jeff Curtis had recently showed me the DADADE tuning and this was the first song I created while playing with it.  (PS: Check out “Out of Eden” by Ben Diamond and Friends for an entire album of original Slack Key instrumental songs in various open tunings, or check out Jeff Curtis’ songs “Goin’ to Colorado” and “Tapioca” so hear the DADADE master himself!)

meta eyJzcmNCdWNrZXQiOiJiemdsZmlsZXMifQ
Son Stone on “Memory of Sugar”: Exploring Temptation, Innocence, and Unexpected Turns in Songwriting 4

7. Your songwriting often features thoughtful storytelling and distinctive acoustic arrangements. Did “Memory of Sugar” come together differently from your other songs, either lyrically or musically?

Yes!  Both lyrically and musically!  I almost always write lyrics first, then melody.  This is one of those rare songs where the chords, melody, and lyrics came together all at the same time.

8. You mentioned that you hesitated to release the track because it ventured into more provocative territory than your listeners might expect. What ultimately changed your mind, and how do you feel about sharing this different side of your creativity?

It’s an unusual release for me.  I have folk and americana-rock under the “Son Stone” name and my older Hawaiian Slack Key recordings under “Ben Diamond and Friends”.  This is more singer-songwriter and doesn’t really match either persona.  I shy away from “personal” or “confessional” writing. Even though this song is based on fictional characters, it feels more personal than my other material, and so, for me, more uncomfortable.

9. Since the song was written in 2014, you’ve had many years to live with it and reflect on it. Has your relationship with the song changed over time, and do you hear it differently today than you did when you first wrote it?

Funny, it’s still a surprising song for me every time I play it or hear it.  My inner voice still questions the lyrics .. “I wrote that?”

10. With “Memory of Sugar,” you’re demonstrating a willingness to follow your creative instincts rather than stick to a familiar formula. Are there other unexpected musical directions or storytelling ideas you’d like to explore in future releases?

Very insightful question!  Since I almost always write the lyrics first, with pen and paper, I’m generally starting with a lyrical form (AABA, or Verse-Chorus-Verse-Chorus-Bridge-Chorus, or a repeating refrain at the end of each verse).  “Memory of Sugar” was intuitively informed by those forms (V-C-V-C-V-CC), but was created, all-at-once.  I’d like to explore writing more extemporaneously like that, more free-flowing .. writing the music and the lyrics at the same time.   I guess it’s time to try a new tuning again to free up my creativity!